Fishy Bottoms

Have you ever, on a nice, cold wintery day, sat outside and stared at an ice-covered pond and wondered if there is anything alive under the ice sheet? No? Well, I was curious enough to recently send off an email about this to a good friend of the Gardens, City of Elkhart’s Aquatic Biologist, Daragh Deegan. This man is sharper than a pike’s tooth and passionate about the aquatic life in the region’s lakes and streams. My previous conception of fish in winter was one of swimmers in a state of hibernation doing nothing, but then I watched a great documentary on fish in alpine lakes. In it, I saw eel spawning in the middle of February…under the ice. Who knew? I did not, so I emailed Mr. Deegan asking if and what the fish in our ponds might be actively doing this time of year. Here is his response to my query. 

JOSH: What are the fish likely doing under the ice in Wellfield’s ponds? Are they just hanging out drifting around twiddling their thumbs?

DARAGH: Unfortunately, while fish may not be twiddling their thumbs during the winter, they are down there twiddling their fin rays. Fish are coldblooded animals whose metabolism and activity is controlled by water temperature. So, when the water in the ponds at the wellfield is 33 degrees, so is the body temperature of the fish. They don’t hibernate in the winter but enter a “torpid state”, where they are very inactive and feeding sparsely. While fish can be caught by ice anglers, their energy requirements are small, so very small baits will only entice them to bite. There are some fish that are a little more active in winter than others. Examples are the northern pike, walleye and yellow perch, which are all considered coldwater species that are found in colder climates. Yellow perch, for example, feed more actively during the winter to nourish their eggs, and spawn very soon after ice melt. 

An interesting phenomenon fish biologists can observe in colder climates like ours is changes in growth rings on a fish scale. As their metabolism slows down in the winter, the growth rings on their scales get closer together, making a banded pattern on the scale, and when viewed under a microscope, we can actually age the fish with these winter growth brands.  

JOSH: Are any other active life forms underwater this time of year doing stuff?

DARAGH: Most aquatic animals become far less active in the winter. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t some kickin it. Larval insects, like some of the midges and stoneflies, are actively feeding and getting ready to transform into flying adults as soon as the ice melts. Like humans, small fur bearing mammals like beavers, muskrats, river otters, and mink are less active in the winter and like to bundle up in their homes, but they need to emerge every few days to grab a bite to eat.  

JOSH: Are there some really cool species or behaviors you think are fun to highlight about freshwater species this time of year?

DARAGH: I think the winter behavior of turtles is really interesting. Like fish, turtles are cold blooded animals that become much less active in the wintertime and will usually sit on the bottom of a pond or stream until the ice melts. The big difference with turtles, however, is they have lungs – not gills, but can survive for days on end under the water in the winter. Their metabolism shifts so they can survive in this semi-dormant state and live off body reserves. They can also pick up some oxygen in the water by swishing around and letting the dissolved oxygen bubbles hit highly vascularized tissue on their body. There’s some sources that suggest that turtles can breathe through their butts.

Okay, on that uplifting factoid, I am going to sign off. Until next time, stay warm, and as my Grandma used to say, “Always listen to the municipal aquatic biologist in your life”.
Josh Steffen, Horticulture and Facilities Manager

Missed seeing Josh’s latest posts? Click on any of these links to learn more:

  • The Importance of Dormancy in Gardening
    During these cold months, gardening activities are rather limited and this time of year can be considered to be an off season for gardeners everywhere. But even though it seems like there is not a lot happening, plants are busy maintaining dormancy. This phase is essential for plants to survive and maintain nutrients.
  • Roll Out the Red Carpet for Squirrels
    National Squirrel Appreciation Day is one of our favorites every year. While our Horticulture staff faces challenges from squirrels, they appreciate them nonetheless! Today, Amy takes a look at ways to welcome and protect squirrels in your yard.
  • Growing Companions
    It’s a gardener’s favorite time of year – or at least one of them – planning for planting time! Today, Ariana looks at one way to help your plants succeed: companion planting.
  • The Spotted Lanternfly
    The spotted lanternfly is an invasive species which, while not yet seen in our area, has been seen in Indiana and Michigan, so it’s just a matter of time. Today, Kyle looks at this pest and shows us what to look for, and what we can do when we “spot” them in our area.
  • Common Species of Christmas Trees
    Merry Christmas! When it comes to Christmas trees, is your family real or fake? (Hint: there is no right or wrong answer) Today, Kyle looks at different species of trees used as Christmas trees and the pros and cons of each.

Want to be notified whenever we post? Enter your email here. We promise not to bug you too much, and we’ll never sell your info.

Leave a Reply